Blue Jays greatest moments
The Toronto Blue Jays are in a rather obvious, and perhaps urgent, state of transition at the moment. Along with all of Major League Baseball, there is the awkward prospect of a looming lockout that has teams scrambling to patch holes and address needs amid a rather thin 2026 free agent class. At least from a perspective of early phase planning, the arrival of Spring Training, and with it, the countless administrative duties required for a franchise to run smoothly, could become complicated, postponed, or outright disrupted.
For the Jays, the calm before the storm might represent more of a mad rush. An unexpected need emerged in 2026: closing the gap between their substantial payroll, which sat fifth among all MLB teams at just over $275 million for 2026, and their abysmal power numbers, evidenced by their 152 team total for home runs, among the lowest in MLB.
For the sake of analytics and acknowledging that perhaps power isn't everything, and that indeed the 2026 World Series champion Milwaukee Brewers finished just two bombs above the Jays, with 154, a more telling statistic, that is, OPS reaffirms that run production came in various ways. The Brew Crew posted a .744 OPS under manager Pat Murphy, while the Jays' skipper John Schneider's team at times had a totally dormant attack, finishing with a .691 OPS.
A Power Outage in Toronto
Adding a new chapter to the mysterious demise of the Jays are musings about their courting of free agent starting pitcher Freddy Peralta, certainly one of the premier names in the once again thin free agent class, but not at all what this club appears to need moving forward, into whatever schedule 2027 should entail.
Perhaps there is hope on the horizon with rookie Sean Keys showing definite pop in a small sample size. The Jays had what appeared to be a promising, power hitting shortstop in Arjun Nimmala, but they sent him to the Los Angeles Angels in a trade just before last season's deadline for, yes, more pitching.
Acquiring right-hander José Soriano, the Jays had an admirable one two punch when paired with ace Dylan Cease, the runner up for the American League Cy Young Award behind unanimous, first time winner Cam Schlittler of the New York Yankees. The club also has Trey Yesavage, Rule-Five pleasant surprise Spencer Miles, and an anomaly in Cody Ponce, who may or may not return from a devastating knee injury. Then there are Spencer Arrighetti, Bowden Francis, and José Berríos, all of whom have had considerable, albeit varying, degrees of success and tenure at the MLB level. The bullpen boasts some of the most effective and durable arms in the game, including workhorse lefty Mason Fluharty and AL Reliever of the Year Louis Varland.
In conclusion, the Jays have an almost abundant surplus of quality arms. The adage that you can never "have enough pitching" is fair, but flashing a four year deal worth more than $100 million to Peralta does not address the most glaring need: power production. What little of it they had is already beginning to walk, as we say goodbye to George Springer and thank him for his formidable efforts with our proud club. We will never forget his three-run homer in Game Seven of the 2025 ALCS, when he took hard-throwing reliever Eduard Bazardo yard to help propel the Jays past the Seattle Mariners and into the World Series.
Apologies in advance for not including Springer's shot in the following top five. Suffice it to say, the wounds of that 2025 World Series are still fresh and not yet sufficiently articulated from a therapeutic perspective by this writer to include that highlight among the fondest memories.
Toronto Blue Jays: Top 5 Greatest Home Runs In Franchise History
Or is it beginning to age, turn sour, and just plain weird? Did Anthony Santander really need to make potentially clubhouse dividing, offensive comments and posts on social media? What happened to the potent switch hitting power that made him one of the most feared hitters, and in turn, most sought after Jays free agent acquisitions in recent years? Did Vladimir Guerrero Jr. need to sound off on the retroactive merits of his $500 million mega contract after barely posting a season of stats in 2026 that justified his place on an MLB roster at the prime age of 27?
The Pain of the Present, and the Memories of the Past
Maybe relief is on the horizon, and Vladdy puts in the work to reinvent his approach at the plate for the upcoming season. It's not only him, well maybe not, as Vlad could definitely benefit from a return of promising talent Addison Barger, a player who offered a much needed offensive spark at just the right time in 2025, before an injury plagued season in '26 kept his left-handed stick from the lineup. Keys continues to impress in batting practice, and backup catcher Brandon Valenzuela has shown promise. But with JoJo Parker still years away from his anticipated big league debut, the Jays are left with only Kazuma Okamoto as their power threat. The club can try to entice Randy Arozarena, Brandon Lowe, or Seiya Suzuki to add pop to this lineup, and that needs to be the priority before things shut down indefinitely.
The Home Runs We Remember
So while we reminisce over the greatest home runs that former sluggers have hit in the most intense, high-profile moments, it is worth recognizing that power, the ability to hit the clutch home run when it really counted, has always been one of the true hallmarks of the team's triumphs. From Doug Ault, who got it started, to Roberto Alomar, Ed Sprague, and "touch 'em all Joe," there is a pure satisfaction in knowing that we had the guy, or guys, to stick the fork in the opposition with a home run when it hurt the most.
More pitching ain't the same, and it won't address that need.
Doug Whiteside is the Founder of The Slam (Scarborough) and a teacher in Toronto. A World Series batboy for the Blue Jays in '92, Doug was in the dugout for at least one of the home runs on this formidable list. He provides weekly takes and podcast episodes on the calls that matter in MLB and the NBA on Keeping Receipts, along with Chris "Furgotti" Furtado. Subscribe to join the discourse, laughs, banter, and debate!
